A partial government shutdown of the Department of Homeland Security appears increasingly likely as Senate Republicans firmly rejected Democratic demands for sweeping immigration enforcement reforms on Thursday, leaving Congress just eight days to reach an agreement before funding expires on February 13. The standoff comes after lawmakers passed a broader spending package this week that funded most federal agencies but deliberately excluded DHS to force negotiations over controversial Immigration and Customs Enforcement operations.
Senate Majority Leader John Thune delivered a stark warning that the department will shut down next week if Democrats do not abandon what he called unrealistic demands for restrictions on federal immigration officers. Senator John Barrasso of Wyoming, the chamber's second-ranking Republican, was even more dismissive, characterizing the Democratic proposals as radical and extreme and describing them as a far-left wish list that Republicans cannot accept.
Democratic leaders unveiled their comprehensive list of demands on Wednesday, seeking to fundamentally reshape how immigration enforcement agencies conduct operations across the country. Topping the list are bans on ICE officers wearing masks to conceal their identities during enforcement actions, along with new rules barring immigration arrests near hospitals, schools, churches, courts, child-care facilities, and other designated sensitive locations. The proposals come in response to enforcement operations that have roiled Minneapolis and other American cities in recent weeks.
The Democratic wish list extends well beyond mask bans and sensitive location protections. Senate Democrats are calling for stricter use of force policies, enhanced legal safeguards at immigration detention centers, and a prohibition on using body-worn cameras to track protesters. They also demand an end to what they describe as indiscriminate arrests, improvements to warrant procedures and standards, and requirements that officers cannot enter private property without obtaining a judicial warrant first.
House Speaker Mike Johnson drew a firm line in the sand regarding warrant requirements, declaring such changes as non-negotiable. At a press conference on Monday, Johnson stated that requiring immigration agents to obtain judicial warrants for arrests and searches is not necessary and represents a road that we cannot or should not go down. He also opposed unmasking ICE agents, citing officer safety concerns, while insisting that immigration law must be enforced regardless of Democratic objections.
Senator Katie Britt of Alabama, who is helping lead negotiations for Republicans, dismissed the Democratic proposals as a ridiculous Christmas list of demands that fails to acknowledge the realities of border security and immigration enforcement. The sharp rhetoric from both sides has left observers increasingly pessimistic about the prospects for reaching a compromise before the February 13 deadline arrives.
With positions so far apart, some lawmakers are openly acknowledging that a DHS shutdown may be unavoidable. One senator warned that the department is going to be shut down for a while, reflecting the profound disagreements over immigration policy that have paralyzed Congress. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer called the situation a gut check moment for Congress, emphasizing the stakes involved as federal immigration enforcement operations continue to generate controversy across the nation. The impasse leaves thousands of DHS employees facing potential furloughs and raises questions about continuity of border security and other critical homeland security functions.
Comments